stop guessing and start understanding your members

What worked five years ago isn’t broken. It’s just irrelevant. Too many associations are still pouring energy into programs and engagement strategies that no longer resonate. Why? Because they’re basing decisions on assumptions—about what members want, how they engage, and what drives value. But here’s the real challenge: changing member expectations are moving faster than most associations can adapt.

Are You Listening—or Guessing? 

Let’s be honest: most engagement strategies are based on gut feeling. 

But your members aren’t who they were in 2019. 

  • They’re busier. 
  • They’re tech-savvier. 
  • They expect personalized, not one-size-fits-all. 

According to .orgSource’s Digital Trends Survey, most associations still rely on basic reporting rather than meaningful data analysis to shape strategy. Just a small fraction are using predictive tools or behavioral insights to really understand member needs. 

If you’re still guessing—or basing decisions on last year’s survey—you’re missing opportunities and risking irrelevance. 

Outdated Assumptions That Ignore Changing Member Expectations 

Let’s bust a few common myths we still hear in boardrooms and staff meetings: 

❌ “Our members prefer in-person.” 
▶️ Some do. Most want options. Hybrid is no longer a trend—it’s a baseline. 

❌ “They don’t want too many emails.” 
▶️ True. But they do want relevant, timely content. It’s not volume; it’s value. 

❌ “Our programs speak for themselves.” 
▶️ They don’t. Members are inundated. If you’re not tailoring, reminding, and re-engaging, you’re invisible. 

❌ “Young professionals just aren’t joiners.” 
▶️ Or maybe your value proposition doesn’t reflect what they need now. Connection looks different for Gen Z. 

5 Simple Tips to Start Rebuilding Your Member Engagement Strategy 

No need to blow up your whole model tomorrow. 

Here are five simple ways to get closer to what your members actually need—right now: 

✅ 1. Ask Better Questions 

Don’t just ask if members are “satisfied.” 
Instead, ask: 

  • What’s the biggest challenge in your day-to-day work? 
  • What are you Googling that you wish we could answer? 
  • What could we stop doing—and you wouldn’t miss it? 

Pro tip: Use polls in emails, community platforms, or even at live events. You don’t need a full survey to get meaningful insights. 

✅ 2. Track Behavior, Not Just Opinions 

If members say they love webinars but never show up—believe their actions, not their words. 

Start simple: 

  • Check your email click-through rates. 
  • Look at your event no-show rate. 
  • See which resource downloads actually get traction. 

Behavioral data tells the truth. Use it to adjust your content, cadence, and channels. 

✅ 3. Personalize Just One Thing 

You don’t need a massive CRM overhaul to start segmenting your audience. 

Pick one area—like event reminders or newsletter content—and personalize based on: 

  • Career stage 
  • Past engagement 
  • Interests or topic preferences 

Even small personalization boosts relevance—and your open rates will thank you. 

✅ 4. Create Micro-Moments of Value 

Your members don’t always have 45 minutes for a webinar. 
But they do have five minutes on the train, in line, or between meetings. 

Start creating: 

  • 3-minute videos 
  • Quick guides 
  • Bite-sized templates 
  • Social-media-friendly member tips 

Meet them where they are, with what they need—when they need it. 

✅ 5. Build Feedback Loops into Everything 

Don’t treat feedback like a once-a-year event. 
Make it a habit. 

Add: 

  • One-question check-ins after webinars 
  • Optional polls on registration pages 
  • Comments or emoji reactions in your online community 

This kind of real-time insight shows trends before your retention rates start slipping. 

What If You’re Getting It Wrong? Good. 

Let’s normalize something: 

Being wrong is a great start. 

It means you’re asking questions. It means you’re listening. 

The worst thing you can do? 
Cling to an outdated idea of your member because “it worked before.” 

Because when you’re building for the past, you’re letting the future slip through your fingers. 

The Real Engagement Strategy for Changing Member Expectations? Stay Curious. 

You don’t need a 100-page playbook. 
You need a bias toward curiosity, iteration, and action. 

And if you’re ready to stop assuming and start adapting—.orgSource is ready to help. 

Whether it’s through digital strategy, data integration, or member experience mapping, we help associations design engagement strategies that actually engage. 

📍 Call to Action: 

→ Want to stop guessing and start understanding your members? 

Talk to us about building your Member Insights Dashboard—or schedule a discovery call with our engagement strategy team. 

Let’s stop assuming. Let’s start evolving. 

Posted in .orgSource, Leadership, Member Engagement and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , ,